Depth VFX’s top 10 animated films

0
20

The animation and special effects team at Depth VFX have compiled, what they considered to be the finest top 10 computer-animated films to date.

The final ten films chosen were from an initial list of 25 films, including 3-D films, stop-motion films, as well as international films including the German film “Back to Gaya‘, French film “Kaena, The Prophecy’, and Spanish film, “The Living Forest‘.

The films that made it through to the top ten have been chosen not only for their aesthetically pleasing visuals, but have been scored out of twenty marks (twenty being the best, one being abysmal), and broken down into four categories, namely Look/Style/Rendering (L), Animation (A), Technological contribution/Advancement/Difficulty (T) and Entertainment (E).

Have a look at Depth’s selection of the top 10 and if you don’t agree or think they’ve missed a significant animated film, let Screen Africa know by emailing editor@screenafrica.com

The top ten (in no particular order) are as follows:

Toy Story (Pixar/Disney. Budget of $30m)L: 4/5

A: 4/5

T: 5/5 – This is because even today, it cannot be faulted on the attention to detail its texturing received. Technologically, this was the first animated feature to be released, and even while no other company or software was even close, the end product still compares well against the latest fancy animated features.

E: 5/5

TOTAL: 18/20

One criticism that counts against Toy Story is the animated Dog, which is weak from both an animation perspective and its basic character design.

Iron Giant (Warner Bros. Animation budget $48m)L: 3/5

A: 5/5

T: 4/5 – This film, directed by Brad Bird, opted to produce one of the hero characters using the 3D animation process, but still adhered to 2D principles, as the film was a traditionally animated feature. The result was the first 2D/3D hero character, and it was successful.

E: 5/5

TOTAL: 17/20

The Incredibles (Pixar/Disney. Budget R92m)L: 3/5

A: 5/5

T: 5/5 – Brand new effects were introduced to assist the story telling. The mom-character had to be able to stretch and align her-self to curved surfaces and yet, still “act’ well. This film made major advancements with digital hair, and even up until four months before release, the technical department was attempting to produce the effect. It also (seemingly) effortlessly included fluid/water effects, ice generation, and cool explosions!

E: 4/5

TOTAL: 17/20

Cars (Pixar. Budget $120m)L: 5/5

A: 5/5

T: 4/5 Ok, so the overall idea of a world populated by cars is the weakest link, other than that, the richness of the world in which the story is told, is remarkably well done. Plus, the cars as characters were technically set up to perform/act perfectly, and yet, to set up a mechanical character to be able to deliver such good performances is beyond the reach of most companies. So many technical difficulties are overcome, simply to help tell a story, as opposed to showing off, which is a testament to Pixar’s love of film.

E: 3/5

TOTAL: 17/20

Shrek (PDI/DreamWorks SKG. Budget unknown)L: 4/5

A: 3/5

T: 4/5 – The forest and fire effects are nicely achieved in this film, but the animation leans towards the weak side. Fluid effects such as the mud on Shrek, and milk pouring into a glass were ahead of their time. But, this film is a good example of how a funny script can cause the audience to not notice any lacking 3D.

E: 5/5

TOTAL: 16/20

Finding Nemo (Pixar/Disney. Budget $94m)L: 5/5

A: 5/5

T: 5/5 – Wow. Wow. No one can deny that Pixar went all out to reproduce the visual beauty only seen in underwater coral reefs. Deftly balanced between realistic and artistic, the sheer volume of technical advancements in this film is intimidating. New advancements achieved were sub-surface scattering (seeing the skeletons/organs inside the fish, mass reef generation with lots of displacement details, and more sub-surface scattering (the light inside the surfaces of the reef elements), fluid dynamics (the water effects inside the whale), the character-setup (again), allowing academy award-winning performances to be squeezed out of the animated characters, oh, and the whole of Sydney as we know it.

E: 4/5

TOTAL: 19/20

Ice Age (Blue Sky. Budget $60m)L: 4/5

A: 5/5

T: 4/5 – Definitely a different look, and a very funny script. The character design of the humans was original, but was interpreted by the audience as just plain bad. The animation is better than Shrek’s, and used Blue Sky’s proprietary renderer, which was the first to implement Global Illumination, which is basically natural light behaviour. The water and ice renders are spectacular.

E: 5/5

TOTAL: 18/20

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here