More SAFTAS controversy?

0
40

Following on from last week’s announcement that Mfundi Vundla had withdrawn Generations from the South African Film & Television Awards (SAFTAS), Screen Africa received an e-mail from one of its readers querying why there were no nominations in the Best Feature Film category.

The reader expressed his surprise at the lack of nominations when there was “quality work such as Meisie, Jerusalema, Triomf, Skin, Disgrace, The World Unseen and Discreet” available.  

Screen Africa contacted SAFTAS co-ordinator Azania Muendane to clarify the period of eligibility which qualified a feature film for entry. Said Muendane: “Eligible films must have been produced and publicly exhibited or broadcast between 31 of October 2006 and 31 March 2008, which is why Jerusalema, for example could not have entered as it was only recently released on circuit. It will of course be eligible for the 2010 SAFTAS. Three feature films did enter the 2009 SAFTAS – Big Fellas, Confessions of a Gambler and The World Unseen.

“It is a concern that we did not receive more entries into this category. However, every attempt was made to contact and encourage all eligible feature film production companies that we were aware of to submit their productions and they made the decision to enter or not.”

As to why there were no nominations in the Best Actor and Best Actress Feature Film categories, Muendane responded. “It is the judges’ decision and cannot be entered into.” She was not at liberty to divulge the names of the Feature Film category judges other than the chair for that panel, Akin Omotoso.

The reader who e-mailed Screen Africa also queried why there were no nominations for Best Short Film, as he had seen “quite a few excellent short films like At Thy Call, Sibahle, Commando, Three Cigarettes, Meokgo and the Stickfigher or Bitter Water”.

Said Muendane: “The judges judged upon what was entered and the results are what have been presented. Please remember that not all productions were entered and the competition is between those that were. Also remember that entry into any competition is a choice that the content owner or designated representative enters. Again, there is the point of eligibility.

“I appreciate the fact that the SAFTAS competition was open to all that were eligible, that it was fair and that the process of judging gave room for open debate, scrutiny and structured analysis of each production. Each level of the SAFTAS process is audited to maintain this.”

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here